SMTP (Simple Mail Transfer Protocol) is the foundation of email delivery. This is essentially how your message travels from your server to the end-user location. But when delivery goes wrong, SMTP servers produce errors with some odd number combinations with a sentence of explanation that, without proper understanding, could make matters worse. Understanding SMTP error codes is crucial to evaluating delivery issues and ensuring proper email activity.
Table of Contents
The Structure of SMTP Error Codes
SMTP error codes are always a three-digit number. The first digit represents the response type: 2 is a success; 4 is a temporary failure; 5 is a permanent failure. The last two digits are more specific as to what the failure may be. SMTP error 451.432 is a common example of a temporary error often related to rate limiting or greylisting. Thus, understanding the pecking order of these codes helps understand whether something needs immediate attention or not; if it does not, it means it will eventually solve itself over time.
For example, a 421 error indicates a recipient mail server is busy and temporarily unavailable; a 550 error indicates a message will not be delivered on a permanent basis because the recipient address does not exist.
Temporary Failures – The 400 Series
SMTP error codes in the 400 series are classified as temporary failures or “soft bounces.” These indicate that although the email message was legitimate and deliverable on any other given day, today the receiving server does not want to or cannot accept it right now. With permanent failures with 5xx errors there’s no chance of the message getting accepted down the line, which means there’s no reason to keep attempting to send to that address in the future; it’s not a valid address anymore, and list cleaning or permanent suppression of that address is the best alternative. The 400-type messages are more like the opposite, a suggestion that maybe down the line, things will be different.
One of the most common soft bounce codes is 421, which generally relays that the receiving mail server is busy or temporarily unavailable. This can happen during peak traffic hours, during maintenance windows, or simply because the server is overloaded or undergoing transient system errors. In these instances, since there’s a possibility the server will accept mail again shortly thereafter, an attempt at redelivery sooner is warranted. Most systems will hold these emails in queue and try redelivery as prescribed thereafter.
Another common soft bounce error is 450 “Requested mail action not taken: mailbox unavailable.” This simply means that the mailbox that was asked for was not available at the time of request. This is most likely the case when a person’s mailbox is full, there is a sporadic disconnection from a server, or an internal sender configuration error. Since it’s temporary, this means that on a second or third try, it might go through on the next attempt, but generally, it means the mailbox has been made available or the sender’s email provider has rectified the situation.
Soft bounces shouldn’t create alarm, but they’re something to be aware of. They’re not fatal flaws, but they should be monitored. If someone is getting a multitude of 4xx errors over time, however, there may be something more wrong than meets the eye and a bounce that could lead to permanent delivery error may occur.
Most email marketing services and transactional email service providers even have in-house retry efforts for 4xx responses. They will wait before resending the email with progressive time delay increases between resends to comply with a number of retry attempts. By the time they reach the ultimate retry attempt, the service will consider the address temporarily undeliverable and not comply with further attempts to that address.
Getting a soft bounce every once in a while is expected and even positive from a deliverability perspective. However, when a measurable percentage of your overall sends all come back with 4xx responses, it shows that something is amiss on your end. You’re either sending too many emails too quickly to too many people, which is triggering your limiters, and Mailgun assumes you’re spamming the platform, and thus, it limits further sends. Or you don’t have a proper DNS setup (SPF, DKIM, or DMARC), and this causes the Mailgun servers to delay accepting the first message.
Understanding what happens with these temporary SMTP efforts and why helps to avoid unnecessary non-deliverability and keeps your message from getting sent into oblivion when it just needs a little more time.
Permanent Failures – The 500 Series
Errors beginning with 5 are permanent issues and a “hard bounce.” These are not to be automatically retried as they are not going to fix themselves any time soon. One of the more popular ones is 550: “Requested action not taken: mailbox unavailable.” This means the intended recipient’s email does not exist or has been disabled/turned off.
Another common issue is 554: “Transaction failed.” This is a vague failed response. This can happen due to content filters, your IP being blacklisted, or the receiving server’s anti-spam policies. These must be investigated and fixed whenever they occur, especially in your email statistics.
Authentication and Relay Errors
Some SMTP errors are not related to the final mailbox and/or mailbox condition. Instead, these errors concern authentication, authorization, and sender validation that must be corrected. Errors like these can hinder successful mail-sending capabilities, and without correction, eventually create a repeat offense when attempts to send mail fail. Instead of hard and soft bounces where messages are rejected because a destination server acknowledges it or that the server is currently overwhelmed these error codes occur before the message is even considered for delivery.
Of all the error codes frequently encountered, though, it’s relatively easy to troubleshoot 530: “Authentication required.” The “authentication required” error typically means that the email server needs the sender to authenticate (log in) before it will send or accept a message. This occurs frequently when a sender attempts to send an email via an SMTP relay authentication without it; a poorly configured email client; a password that has changed or is expiring; or authentication settings forgotten in a user’s own email server/email marketing services. To alleviate this error, the sender must access the SMTP settings to check the username/password fields are properly filled and that outgoing mail is set to allow for authentication.
Yet another frequent error is 553: “Requested action not taken: mailbox name not allowed.” This usually indicates a problem with the sender’s email address. It’s malformed meaning it doesn’t have the ‘@’ sign or domain or it exists on a domain which the SMTP server is not meant to acknowledge or allow. However, at the same time, the server could be rejecting the message because it thinks there’s an improper relay, and it doesn’t want to do so. SMTP relays are designed to prevent relaying for an anti-spam mechanism, so if you’re trying to send something on an SMTP server that has not been correctly configured to acknowledge your domain or email address, it will reject your request to send email on another email’s behalf.
These types of authentication or permission errors are most common when creating new email accounts, creating an outbound SMTP server for the first time, or attempting to link other platforms (like CRMs or marketing platforms) to your SMTP service provider. Anything from a wrong “From” address, SMTP authentication turned off, or relay permissions turned off can generate these types of errors.
Plus, by fixing these issues, you not only remedy the on-site error, but you also boost your sender reputation and deliverability. Increasingly, email services rely on authentication as a key trust factor. Reducing complications and making sure your domain passes authentication checks every time only aids against being marked as spam, increases the likelihood of reaching the inbox, and shields your business from potential spoofing.
Ultimately, by resolving SMTP authentication errors 530 and 553 before they cause any issues, you’re striving for an effective technical empire on the backend for effective and secure email transmission.
Content and Policy-Based Blocks
Sometimes, your email can be deliverable in that it can technically be sent and received but still be blocked based on content or your sending history. For example, a 552 error can occur when a message is too large for the intended recipient’s server to accept. If you send many emails with large attachments or images embedded, this could become an ongoing issue.
A 554 error can occur when your domain or IP is blacklisted as spam. In this case, it’s not a content policy violation or mistake in connecting to a server. Still, it’s essential to monitor blacklists and ensure compliance to avoid such blocks based on sender reputation.
How to Troubleshoot SMTP Errors Effectively
Understanding SMTP error codes in context aids in error resolution. Analyze sending logs and bounce reports for trends and frequent errors. For instance, if the 550 error manifests several times for many users under the same domain, then either the destination mail server is at fault, or your DNS record isn’t set up properly.
Employing various email and SMTP testing tools allows you to send on your end and inquire with the receiving server for more error details. Furthermore, checking SPF, DKIM, and DMARC can help shed some light as proper authentication should mitigate relay errors.
Preventing SMTP Errors with Best Practices
Ultimately, the best way to reduce SMTP errors is through proper email sending. Keep a clean, updated mailing list so you’re not accidentally sending improper and invalid addresses. Also, try to segment and target audiences and customize content, as this conversion decreases disinterest and spam flagging potential. Furthermore, throttle sending volumes for new campaigns and with new IP addresses. New campaigns/new IPs may be well-intentioned, but they raise red flags for volume increases. Incremental increases establish trust with Internet Service Providers (ISPs) and prevent errors related to bounces.
When to Seek Help from Your ESP or IT Team
When you’re receiving unexplained SMTP errors or if your email does not go through even after seemingly perfect setup, it’s time to contact your ESP or internal IT. They can parse the unfiltered server response, check the logs, and ensure your sending behavior is questionable.
Furthermore, issues such as IP blacklisting and domain reputation might not even be in your hands to fix, they require your ESP to do so. On the other hand, some fixes involve DNS or server-level adjustments that only trained professionals should make.
Conclusion
Understanding SMTP errors is important for more than just problem solving. A clear understanding of what these errors mean translates almost instantaneously to diagnosing a quicker solution, applying it, and preserving a healthy sender reputation. Whether you’re a novice email marketer or someone who’s been doing it for years, the awareness of SMTP errors will have you in the know at best when it comes to an unknown digital delivery realm.